When it comes to starting a business on Amazon, one of the most common questions new sellers ask is: “Should I go private label or wholesale?”
Both models are legitimate ways to build an Amazon FBA business, but they come with very different levels of risk, cost, and complexity. In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences between Amazon FBA private label vs wholesale, and explain why, in most cases—especially for beginners—wholesale is the better route.
________________________________________
What is Amazon Private Label?
Private labelling involves creating your own brand and having a manufacturer produce a product that you sell under that brand name. While this model offers total control over your branding, pricing, and customer experience, it also comes with some serious challenges:
• You’ll need to research and design a product that stands out in the market.
• You’re responsible for packaging, listing creation, and branding.
• You’ll likely need to invest in advertising and influencer marketing to build visibility.
• There’s no guarantee the product will sell, especially without an established track record.
Many sellers are attracted to private label because it offers the potential to build a unique brand and higher margins. But it’s also high-risk, expensive, and time-consuming—particularly for those just starting out.
_______________________________________
What is Amazon Wholesale?
Wholesale means buying products in bulk from established brands and reselling them on Amazon. You’re not creating new products—you’re sourcing products that already exist and already sell well.
This model is ideal for sellers who want to move quickly, minimise risk, and scale efficiently. With wholesale, you:
• Leverage existing demand for branded products.
• Skip product development and go straight to selling.
• Can scale by building strong supplier relationships.
• Avoid many of the upfront costs and delays associated with private label.
________________________________________
Private Label vs Wholesale – A Direct Comparison
| Feature | Private Label | Wholesale |
|---|---|---|
| Startup Cost | High (branding, MOQ, ads) | Moderate (stock-only investment) |
| Time to Launch | Slow (sampling, design) | Fast (stock & go live) |
| Marketing Required | High (brand building) | Minimal (brands already known) |
| Risk Level | High (unknown demand) | Lower (established sales data) |
| Scalability | Medium–High (takes time) | High (repeat orders, supplier scale) |
| Control Over Brand | Full | Limited |
| Entry Barrier | High | Moderate |
________________________________________
Why Wholesale is the Smarter Option for Most Sellers
Let’s be clear—private label isn’t a bad model, but for new or growing Amazon sellers, wholesale simply makes more sense. Here’s why:
1. Lower Upfront Risk
With wholesale, you’re buying products that already sell well on Amazon. You can check historical sales data using tools like Keepa and AMZScout, which means you’re making decisions based on real performance—not guesses.
2. Faster Time to Market
No branding. No packaging design. No waiting on samples. You find a supplier, place your order, and get those products into Amazon’s warehouse. It’s that simple.
3. No Need for Costly Marketing
Private label sellers often spend hundreds or thousands on PPC campaigns to get noticed. With wholesale, your products are already ranked, already reviewed, and already trusted by Amazon customers.
4. Scalable and Sustainable
Once you’ve built relationships with suppliers and proven sales, you can scale up your orders, request better pricing, and even get access to exclusive stock. It’s a reliable, repeatable growth model.
5. Predictable Profits
Wholesale allows for accurate ROI forecasting because you can see the exact fees, profit margins, and competition in advance. That level of clarity is rare in private label.
________________________________________
But Isn’t Wholesale Too Competitive?
Not if you’re sourcing strategically. Many wholesalers or distributors have brand restrictions and exclusive terms, meaning not every seller can list the same products. If you build strong relationships and offer value to your suppliers, you’ll gain access to deals others can’t get.
And remember—competition is only a problem if you’re selling the same product, the same way, to the same people. With wholesale, there’s still room for savvy sourcing and smart strategy.
________________________________________
When Does Private Label Make Sense?
• Private label can be a great option once you’ve built experience and capital. If you have:
• A clear product idea with market demand
• Sufficient budget to test and refine your product
• A long-term brand vision and time to grow it
Then yes, private label could be a good fit. But for most sellers starting out, it’s a slower, riskier path.
________________________________________
Start with Wholesale, Then Diversify
Many successful Amazon sellers begin with wholesale to learn the platform, generate cash flow, and understand logistics. Once they’ve gained confidence and capital, they might then invest in building a private label brand.
But wholesale offers the fastest route to real results, especially if you’re working with a service that helps you identify profitable leads, trusted suppliers, and proven products.
________________________________________
Final Thoughts
If you’re looking for:
• A lower-risk entry point into Amazon FBA
• A faster way to start selling and generating revenue
• A business model you can scale with confidence
Then wholesale is your best option. You don’t need to reinvent the wheel—you just need to find the right products, the right suppliers, and the right support.
________________________________________
Ready to get started with Amazon FBA wholesale?
Explore the Deal Hunters FBA Wholesale Course or check out our Daily Deal Sheets for high-ROI product leads, vetted suppliers, and hands-on support.
